
When you run something every month for ten years, you start to notice what changes and what doesn’t.
Since 2016, around 14,000 people from more than 50 countries, most of them women, have come through Elevate. They’ve worked in engineering, pharmaceuticals, energy, technology, manufacturing and finance. They’ve joined in different years, from different companies, in very different times. Some came in the middle of a pandemic. Some came in the middle of a restructure.
And yet, when they arrive, they describe themselves in almost exactly the same way.
That’s what this piece is about. Not who gets overlooked, which I wrote about recently, but the fact that every group starts in the same place. I think it’s the most important thing our data shows.
The same starting line, every time
Everyone who joins Elevate completes a self-assessment before they start. It’s how we tailor the programme, so nobody can skip it. In 2023 we expanded it into twenty statements across our four EPIC areas: Exposure, Performance, Impact and Conscious.
We ask everyone to complete it again at the end of the year. Not everyone does, but since the expanded version, about 2,000 people have completed it at both the start and the end. Their answers are what this piece is based on.
Each person’s score places them in one of four categories:
- Star – performing exceptionally, ready for further fine-tuning
- Strong – performing well, with the potential to become a star
- Steady – consistent, with clear changes that would speed up their career
- Stationary – not yet moving forward, with plenty of room to grow
What strikes me most is how little the starting picture changes from one year to the next.
In every one of the nine:
- No more than 3% started as a Star
- Between one and two in ten started as Strong.
- Around four in ten started as Steady.
- Between a third and almost half started as Stationary.
Different years. Different companies. The same result.
If this were about individuals, you’d expect much more variation from one year to the next. That didn’t happen. Whoever arrived, they arrived in the same place.
When something comes out the same no matter who you put in, it tells you this isn’t about any one person, or any one company.
What they’re sure of
Some answers were almost unanimous.
Nearly everyone says their colleagues trust them. Nine in ten say the people around them see their potential. Most say they know their strengths, and that they achieve what they set out to do.
And they’re confident. Around eight in ten say so. Very few avoid the risk of failing, and very few dislike change.
This isn’t new. In our earlier monthly polls, going back years before the expanded assessment, between 78% and 92% told us they were confident in their abilities.
I’ve said for years that confidence isn’t the problem, and this is why. These are capable, trusted people who know they’re good at what they do.
What they’re not sure of
Then there are the questions where the answers fall apart.
Only one in five spends any time each week on their career. Most say plainly that they don’t. They know it’s a gap, and they say so.
That isn’t new either. Across five years of our monthly polls, the share who strongly agreed they make sure others know the value they bring never went above 12%.
But the most revealing answers weren’t a “no”. They were a “don’t know”.
Four in ten didn’t know whether people speak well of them when they’re not in the room. Hardly anyone thought the answer was bad. They simply had no idea. Many were also unsure whether they handle the politics of their organisation well, or whether people follow when they take the lead.
So up close, they’re sure. They know they’re trusted, relied on and good at the work. What they can’t see is how they’re talked about where decisions get made.
You can hear it in their own words. In every session, people could send us their comments or burning question. We’ve never shared who asked what, and we won’t start now. But some of those questions said more than any statistic:
“I think that person knows, likes and trusts me, but in reality they think otherwise – and it was never revealed to me.”
“How can I get feedback about whether they trust me? I think they do.”
“How do you make someone know you without talking too much about yourself?”
“I talked to my manager about a promotion, which he just ignored me, and he didn’t explain what I needed to do.”
And one I’ve never forgotten:
“Shouldn’t we fake it until we make it, and rate all of our skills as ten – like most men do?”
What a year can change
By the end of the year, almost every answer had moved.
The share who were Star or Strong roughly doubled. The number spending time on their career each week more than doubled, to around half. And the “don’t knows” halved. Far more people now had a sense of how they were seen, and of how to navigate the politics around them.
At the end of each year, somewhere between a quarter and almost half told us they’d been promoted or moved role.
I want to be honest about what this can and can’t tell us. These are people rating themselves, and the people who complete both assessments may not be typical of everyone who joins. There’s also no comparison group of people who didn’t take part. So, I can’t prove the programme caused every one of these changes. What I can say is that they happened, consistently, year after year.
What stays hardest to move
Some things moved less.
Even at the end, fewer than half spend time on their career each week. The Conscious area, which covers knowing your strengths and reading your organisation, stayed the weakest of the four in every group. And some people still had no idea how they were spoken about when they weren’t there.
I don’t think that’s because they didn’t try. I think it’s because some of the information they need isn’t theirs to find. You can learn to ask for feedback, and our participants did. But you can’t read a talent review you’ve never been invited to see.
What it adds up to
Ten years, thousands of people, and the same pattern every time.
They’re trusted, capable and confident in their work. Then they hit a gap: knowing how they’re seen beyond their own team, finding time to plan their own career, reading the politics. We saw signs of it in our monthly polls for years. The expanded assessment showed it in detail, and it was still there in 2025. It showed up in every group, whichever companies and countries they came from.
That consistency tells me two things.
The first is that organisations don’t make it easy. The way potential gets spotted isn’t written down anywhere, and it rarely rewards the quiet, reliable work these people are so good at.
The second is that many of them have never been shown how it actually works. How decisions really get made. Who needs to know what you can do. Why an hour a week on your own career matters as much as another hour on the job.
You can debate whether the system should work that way. Whether it’s fair, or right, or likely to change. It may well change over time. But that doesn’t help you if you’re sitting there today, wanting a promotion that isn’t coming.
That’s why Elevate exists. Not to wait for the system to change, but to help capable people, understand how it works today, and succeed in it.
In my next piece, I’ll share what ten years of doing this work has taught me.
About the data
- Around 14,000 people, most of them women, have taken part in Elevate since 2016. All of them completed a self-assessment before starting.
- The confidence and self-promotion figures from earlier years come from our monthly session polls.
- All other figures come from the expanded self-assessment introduced in 2022, completed at both the start and the end of the programme by around 1,650 people between 2022 and 2025.
- The participants’ questions are quoted without names and lightly edited for spelling and grammar.